ScotchParty Review #3 – BattleScotch! The Glendronach 12y Original v The Glenrothes Select Reserve with Jared, Ashley, Alex, Goran, Ryan, Dan & Bowick

BATTLESCOTCH AT A SCOTCHPARTY. THE BATTLE OF THE GLENS.

Sorry for the shouting.  We pitted The Glendronach 12y Original against The Glenrothes Select Reserve literally because they both have Glen in the name – The GlenDronach is an aged expression Highlander and The Glenrothes is a non-specific Speysider, so it really was the only axis of comparison. Here’s what we thought:

smell
Simon – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Jared – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Ashley – The Glendronach 12y Original
Alex – The Glendronach 12y Original
Dan – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Goran – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Ryan – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Bowick – The Glendronach 12y Original

neat
Simon – The Glendronach 12y Original
Jared – The Glendronach 12y Original
Ashley – The Glendronach 12y Original
Alex – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Dan – The Glendronach 12y Original
Goran – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Ryan – The Glenrothes Select Reserve
Bowick -The Glenrothes Select Reserve

splash
Simon – The Glendronach 12y Original
Jared – The Glendronach 12y Original
Ashley – The Glendronach 12y Original
Alex – The Glendronach 12y Original
Dan – The Glendronach 12y Original
Goran – n/a
Ryan – n/a
Bowick -n/a

The GlenDronach 12y Original v The Glenrothes Select Reserve = GlenDronach with a splash